| Relevant Industry Experience |
15% |
Experience with the same voltage class, installation environment, switching duties, and utility or industrial application. |
Documented project references, technical case studies, commissioning records, and experience with comparable operating conditions. |
Project-specific specifications; applicable IEC, IEEE, or national standards. |
1 = No comparable experience 3 = Some relevant projects 5 = Extensive directly comparable experience |
| Product Design and Voltage Rating |
12% |
Rated voltage, rated insulation level, rated normal current, short-time withstand current, peak withstand current, and short-circuit duration. |
Complete technical data sheets, type-test reports, single-line diagrams, interface drawings, and verified design calculations. |
IEC 62271-1; IEC 62271-200 for metal-enclosed AC switchgear up to and including 52 kV; IEC 62271-203 for AC gas-insulated metal-enclosed switchgear above 52 kV. |
1 = Incomplete data 3 = Meets basic requirements 5 = Fully verified with design margin |
| Manufacturing Quality and Process Control |
15% |
Control of enclosure fabrication, conductor assembly, sealing systems, insulation components, torque values, cleanliness, and traceability. |
Factory audit results, manufacturing procedures, inspection and test plans, calibrated equipment records, batch traceability, and nonconformance procedures. |
ISO 9001 quality-management system certification; documented internal quality-control procedures. |
1 = No documented controls 3 = Basic process controls 5 = Auditable and consistently documented controls |
| Routine and Type Testing Capability |
15% |
Ability to perform or arrange required electrical, mechanical, dielectric, gas-tightness, and functional tests before shipment. |
Valid type-test reports, routine-test certificates for each production unit, test equipment calibration certificates, and independent laboratory records where required. |
IEC 62271-1; IEC 62271-200 or IEC 62271-203, depending on the equipment rating and configuration. |
1 = Limited testing evidence 3 = Standard tests available 5 = Complete, traceable, independently verified testing |
| Certifications and Regulatory Compliance |
12% |
Validity and scope of management-system certificates, product compliance documents, and country-specific approvals. |
Current certificates showing the legal entity, certified scope, issuing body, certificate validity, and applicable manufacturing location. |
ISO 9001; ISO 14001 for environmental management; ISO 45001 for occupational health and safety, where applicable. |
1 = Missing or expired documents 3 = Basic valid certifications 5 = Comprehensive, current, and scope-relevant certification portfolio |
| Gas Management and Environmental Controls |
10% |
Gas selection, filling procedures, leakage prevention, recovery, storage, transport, maintenance, and end-of-life handling. |
Gas-handling procedures, leak-test records, recovery equipment details, safety data, environmental controls, and documented maintenance instructions. |
IEC 62271-4 for handling procedures for gases used in high-voltage switchgear and controlgear; applicable local environmental and safety regulations. |
1 = No formal gas-control process 3 = Basic documented procedures 5 = Complete closed-loop gas-management system |
| Reliability and Sealing Performance |
8% |
Long-term performance of gas compartments, seals, pressure-monitoring devices, operating mechanisms, and interlocking systems. |
Leak-rate test results, pressure-monitoring specifications, accelerated or endurance test data, failure-rate records, and preventive-maintenance requirements. |
Applicable IEC 62271 product standards and the project-specified gas-tightness requirements. |
1 = Unsupported reliability claims 3 = Standard reliability evidence 5 = Detailed, verified, and application-specific evidence |
| Protection, Control, and Interlocking |
8% |
Mechanical and electrical interlocks, control wiring, protection-interface compatibility, remote operation, alarms, and status indication. |
Control schematics, interlocking logic, communication-interface documentation, functional-test records, and cybersecurity information where digital control is used. |
Project specifications; IEC 62271 requirements; applicable IEC 61850 requirements for substation communication, where specified. |
1 = Limited interface information 3 = Standard control functions 5 = Fully documented and tested integration |
| After-Sales Service and Spare Parts |
8% |
Availability of commissioning support, training, troubleshooting, spare parts, maintenance tools, and technical documentation. |
Service response procedure, spare-parts list, recommended maintenance schedule, training program, warranty terms, and local service capability. |
Project maintenance requirements and applicable occupational-safety procedures. |
1 = No defined support 3 = Standard warranty and documentation 5 = Structured long-term service support |
| Delivery, Documentation, and Supply-Chain Control |
3% |
Production planning, critical-component sourcing, inspection hold points, packaging, transport protection, and document control. |
Manufacturing schedule, quality-plan milestones, approved-vendor controls, packing specifications, document register, and delivery-performance records. |
ISO 9001 procedures; contractual project-documentation requirements. |
1 = Unclear delivery controls 3 = Defined schedule and documentation 5 = Strongly controlled and transparent supply chain |
| Lifecycle Cost and Sustainability |
2% |
Purchase price, installation, testing, maintenance, gas handling, energy losses, spare parts, and end-of-life requirements. |
Total-cost-of-ownership calculation, maintenance intervals, energy-loss data, retrofit options, recycling procedures, and decommissioning instructions. |
ISO 14001 where applicable; relevant environmental regulations and project sustainability requirements. |
1 = Purchase price only 3 = Basic lifecycle estimate 5 = Transparent and quantified lifecycle assessment |